alicu blog

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, January 10, 2014

ANOTHER LIBERTARIAN MARKET FAILURE

Posted on 10:14 AM by dimple
Peter Suderman, talking about the GOP's Obamacare strategy, seems disappointed that Republicans have been reluctant to propose sweeping changes to the nation's health care scheme besides Repeal Because Freedom. His Republican sources also complain of it, with (considering the Party's historic obstructionist approach to all things Obama)  breathtakingly transparent insincerity: One of them -- "'We don't have a Republican majority that remembers how to govern and understands how to juggle trade­offs,' one health policy aide complains" -- actually made me laugh out loud.

As you would expect, Suderman gives a favorable hearing to the ideas of libertarian-conservative wonks:
In a 2009 paper, "Yes, Mr. President: A Free Market Can Fix Health Care"...
What'd I tell you?
...[Cato Institute Health Policy Director Michael] Cannon laid out a plan for converting Medicare into a voucher system (he now favors Social Security-style direct payments to enrollees), ending state-based monopolies on both insurance and clinician licensing, capping federal spending on Medicaid through block grants, and eliminating the tax preference for employer-sponsored health care. 
Eliminating that tax preference, which since World War II has allowed employers to purchase health coverage for employees on a tax advantaged basis, would actually result in a substantial tax cut, Cannon argues counter-intuitively.
I'll say it's counterintuitive. So is the rest of it, for those of us who've been trained by decades of experience to hear "ending state-based monopolies," "capping federal spending," etc. as the patter of privatization bunco artists.
If employers cashed out the amount they now pay for health insurance, workers with family coverage would see an average compensation increase of $11,000.
Question for my readers residing in workaday reality: If your boss got a $11,000 windfall, would you expect him to forward it to you?  (These are the same people who'll tell you that if your landlord is absolved of rent control and can charge any rent he likes, he'll lower yours.)
The trick would be to replace that tax preference with the creation of very large health savings accounts-tax-free savings that could be applied toward health purchases. Versions of these accounts exist today, but they are capped at $3,300 for individual coverage and $6,550 for families; Cannon's proposal would dramatically increase the cap, perhaps tripling it, and in the process free thousands in individual income both from taxation and from employer control. The result would be to simultaneously give individuals control of thousands of dollars in compensation now tied up in employer health benefits, while eliminating the government-granted financial advantage of employer-provided coverage. Individuals, and not their employment status, would then dictate health insurance coverage.
And if that worker bee, freed from the necessity of paying into a liberty-restricting group insurance program, finds his car needs a new transmission and his home needs a new boiler, and he doesn't put as much into that savings account as he'd planned, and suddenly gets cancer, it's sad trombone time (though libertarians won't feel sad themselves, because Moochers Have It Coming).

Suderman also talks about last year's government shutdown; he knows it was unpopular and counterproductive, but he doesn't appear to know why. It's simple: The nation may dislike Obamacare, but that doesn't mean they prefer Pay or Die.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • REPUBLICAN OUTREACH TO WOMEN CONTINUES.
    Good catch, Dr. Spencer : It's by Patrick Howley at The Daily Caller. Spencer believes it to be "officially the Dumbest Thing on t...
  • CONSERVATIVE MINORITY OUTREACH CONTINUES.
    Shorter Aaron Goldstein : I apologize to readers of The American Spectator -- when I celebrated Hank Aaron's baseball career, I didn...
  • EXTREMISM IN DEFENSE OF FREEBIES IS NO VICE.
    When I wrote last weekend about the Bundy Ranch situation -- in which Sagebrush Rebels threatened U.S. federal officers with violence -- I ...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about week 2 of the shutdown and the gloom gathering on the right .  Not everyone's down, though: Here's Doug Ross  with a listic...
  • SCAMDAL.
    Conservatives are all rushing forward with their dollies, showing where Big Gummint gave them bad touch. Among my favorites is Stanley Kurtz...
  • CRAZY JESUS LADY'S CRISIS OF AUTHORITY.
    Peggy Noonan has reanimated Robert Taft so that he may opine on the recent shutdown. I gotta tell you, folks, I hardly know what to do with...
  • (no title)
    NEW VOICE COLUMN UP , about the news that the U.S. birth rate is way down and how rightbloggers have reacted to it. Short version: This is...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about the Crimea crisis and the rightblogger angle that a real man/President would be kicking Putin's ass right now -- you know, lik...
  • MAN OF CONSTANT SORROW.
    As I was watching the Coen Brothers 60s-folk-scene movie Inside Llewyn Davis I thought: Boy, sometimes the Coens just dump shit on a guy. ...
  • NOTHING MEANS NOTHING ANYMORE.
    At PJ Media, Rand Simberg headlines, We are all scientists and uses a cute, familiar routine to demonstrate this ("If you’ve ever gone...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2014 (179)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (28)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ►  March (24)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ▼  January (28)
      • GO AHEAD, TRY IT THAT WAY.
      • BUT SOME ARE MORE UNEQUAL THAN OTHERS.
      • NOT WORTHY OF OUR TIME.
      • HE WHO FEELS IT, KNOWS IT.
      • WATCH YOUR BACK, GOLDBERG.
      • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • STUPIDEST, WRITTEN, GOLDBERG, AGAIN*.
      • THE SPECIAL-NEEDS CHILDREN OF ZHDANOV.
      • TODAY IN CAREER ADVANCEMENT.
      • SHORTER OLE PERFESSER INSTAPUNDIT: I'M NOT NUTS, Y...
      • IF YOU CELEBRATE MLK DAY BY DENOUNCING AFFIRMATIVE...
      • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • ANNALS OF THE CULTURE WARS, "LIBERALS LOVE BLACK P...
      • WHY ARE YOU AFRAID OF ME, BABY-KILLING BITCH?
      • SOMETIMES YOU HAVE TO LET THE SUCKERS WIN.
      • MISS PARKER'S MAGICAL CONCOCTION.
      • SENEX IRATUS OTD.
      • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • ANOTHER LIBERTARIAN MARKET FAILURE
      • THURSDAY MISCELLANY.
      • FORCED TO DRAW BENEFITS: A CONSERVATIVE'S HEARTBRE...
      • THE MARRIAGE-MAKES-YOU-RICH ARGUMENT AGAINST THE M...
      • ANNALS OF THE CULTURE WARS, PART 432,239.
      • IDENTITY POLITICS.
      • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • AND THE WOLF THAT SHALL KEEP IT MAY PROSPER.
      • ONE'S GOOD; TWO'LL GET YOU OFF.
      • WELL-BEGUN IS HALF DONE.
  • ►  2013 (286)
    • ►  December (23)
    • ►  November (24)
    • ►  October (23)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (24)
    • ►  June (24)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (28)
    • ►  March (23)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (28)
  • ►  2012 (35)
    • ►  December (25)
    • ►  November (10)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

dimple
View my complete profile