alicu blog

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, March 14, 2013

HOW YOU KNOW YOU'RE WINNING.

Posted on 9:21 PM by dimple
Back in December, James Taranto of the Wall Street Journal had an article headlined, "The Sure Thing? Reconsidering a prediction about same-sex marriage." Though a few years earlier he had predicted gay marriage would win the day when the Supreme Court got hold of it, Taranto said, "now we're not so sure." (As he also described a pro-gay-marriage decision not as one that would enfranchise millions of his fellow citizens, but as one that would "declare the traditional definition of marriage unconstitutional," you know where his rooting interest lies.)

In a new column, Taranto returns to the subject and pulls what he probably considers a clever trick play:
The administration does not go so far as to urge the court to strike down all state bans on same-sex marriage. Instead it urges a novel solution that would have the effect of abolishing nonmarital civil unions, until now the compromise of choice between supporters and opponents of same-sex marriage.
You can hear the chortles in CPAC back rooms: Heh indeed, by pushing "gay" "marriage" Obama's killing civil unions! How do you like that, gay people? You should join us at CPAC -- er, on the downlow.

This schtick comes with rhetorical appurtenances. One: You're Denying Our Right to Self-Expression:
As a legal matter, the administration's position seems odd. The effect of banning same-sex marriage in civil-union states is purely expressive: The states are in effect declaring that homosexual relationships are inferior to marriages. That is a value judgment with which many people disagree, but why should the state not be free to express it--especially when the expression has no material effect?
Two: Obama is Applying the "Chicago Way" to His Fellow Travelers and They Will Fall In Line:
The likeliest answer is political: that the administration has concluded (or anticipates that the court, which is to say Justice Kennedy, will conclude) that imposing same-sex marriages nationwide would be disruptive in the way Roe v. Wade was--but the civil-union states are socially liberal enough that they would accept such a ruling.
Three: You're Only Hurting Yourself:
For supporters of same-sex marriage, however, there's a danger that adopting this legal compromise would shut down an avenue of political compromise.
These are not the kind of arguments you hear when you're losing. The struggle will continue, as it still does over the civil rights of black Americans. But the losing side will become increasingly legalistic, hair-splitting, and petty. That's how you know you're winning.

UPDATE. Speaking of which, here's Rick Moran reacting to the news that GOP macher Rob Portman, inspired by his gay son, has turned over on marriage equality:
As more and more Americans realize that they are related to, or work with, or live next to someone who is gay, it is inevitable that acceptance follows. This doesn't mean that opposing gay marriage is bigoted. People of good conscience can disagree (something the left refuses to acknowledge while trying to ram gay marriage down the throats of people by co-opting the legisalture and using the courts to gain their objective).
Translation: Yes, we're getting tolerant, but what about all these homosexuals trying to ram their big, hard gay marriage down my throat? Where's their tolerance?

I expect the brighter bulbs among the rightbloggers will keep quiet or roll more gently with it. Maybe we'll see a pro-equality, anti-drone Republican Party in 2016. Baby steps!
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • REPUBLICAN OUTREACH TO WOMEN CONTINUES.
    Good catch, Dr. Spencer : It's by Patrick Howley at The Daily Caller. Spencer believes it to be "officially the Dumbest Thing on t...
  • CONSERVATIVE MINORITY OUTREACH CONTINUES.
    Shorter Aaron Goldstein : I apologize to readers of The American Spectator -- when I celebrated Hank Aaron's baseball career, I didn...
  • EXTREMISM IN DEFENSE OF FREEBIES IS NO VICE.
    When I wrote last weekend about the Bundy Ranch situation -- in which Sagebrush Rebels threatened U.S. federal officers with violence -- I ...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about week 2 of the shutdown and the gloom gathering on the right .  Not everyone's down, though: Here's Doug Ross  with a listic...
  • SCAMDAL.
    Conservatives are all rushing forward with their dollies, showing where Big Gummint gave them bad touch. Among my favorites is Stanley Kurtz...
  • CRAZY JESUS LADY'S CRISIS OF AUTHORITY.
    Peggy Noonan has reanimated Robert Taft so that he may opine on the recent shutdown. I gotta tell you, folks, I hardly know what to do with...
  • (no title)
    NEW VOICE COLUMN UP , about the news that the U.S. birth rate is way down and how rightbloggers have reacted to it. Short version: This is...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about the Crimea crisis and the rightblogger angle that a real man/President would be kicking Putin's ass right now -- you know, lik...
  • MAN OF CONSTANT SORROW.
    As I was watching the Coen Brothers 60s-folk-scene movie Inside Llewyn Davis I thought: Boy, sometimes the Coens just dump shit on a guy. ...
  • NOTHING MEANS NOTHING ANYMORE.
    At PJ Media, Rand Simberg headlines, We are all scientists and uses a cute, familiar routine to demonstrate this ("If you’ve ever gone...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2014 (179)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (28)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ►  March (24)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (28)
  • ▼  2013 (286)
    • ►  December (23)
    • ►  November (24)
    • ►  October (23)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (24)
    • ►  June (24)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (28)
    • ▼  March (23)
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • REPUBLICAN MINORITY OUTREACH CONTINUES.
      • PROBLEM SOLVED.
      • SHORTER MICHAEL WALSH:
      • LITTLE MRS. CAN'T BE WRONG.
      • ANNALS OF THE CULTURE WARS, SPECIAL BREITBART EDIT...
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • WEDDING BALLS.
      • NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT.
      • SHITSVILLE U.S.A.
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP....
      • HOW YOU KNOW YOU'RE WINNING.
      • SHORTER PEGGY NOONAN:
      • LOOKING IN ON OLD FRIENDS.
      • FAMILY VALUES.
      • DRAMA QUEEN.
      • A HANDUP NOT A HANDOUT.
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP...
      • THE OTHER MAN BOOB.
      • #StandWithThatAssholeRandPaul.
      • A DUNCIAD OF CONFEDERATES.
      • WHEN SLAVE GIRL PRINCESS LEIA ISN'T ENOUGH.
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP...
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (28)
  • ►  2012 (35)
    • ►  December (25)
    • ►  November (10)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

dimple
View my complete profile