alicu blog

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Posted on 6:31 AM by dimple
THUMBS DOWN. I hate to get on Glenn Greenwald's bad side but his claim that he isn't really reviewing-without-having-seen Zero Dark Thirty, when his hostile non-review contains phrases like this --
That this film would depict CIA interrogation programs as crucial in capturing America's most hated public enemy, and uncritically herald CIA officials as dramatic heroes, is anything but surprising.
--and--
...the film's glorifying claims about torture are demonstrably, factually false.
--and--
What this film does, then, is uncritically presents as fact the highly self-serving, and factually false, claims by the CIA...
-- is extremely disingenuous. Greenwald's points about some of the journalism surrounding the film are valid, but his characterizations of the film itself are ridiculous. Zero Dark Thirty isn't a shadowy political figure whose hidden movements you track by eyewitness reports. It's a fucking movie. Have your editor buy you a ticket.

This is still more proof -- as if more were needed -- that you shouldn't bring your political obsessions to the temple of art. It is both more personally edifying and more pleasing to the Muses to approach a work of art as a work of art, however obnoxious it may be to you on other grounds, than to approach it as a political phenomenon. Because when you do the latter, you get into company you really don't want to be keeping.

If the thing you've actually seen, heard, or read is a piece of shit, then fire away.

I would explain further, yet again, why this is so, but I'm busy and I assume adults already know this.

UPDATE. Lotta pushback in comments. Like I said, what people are saying about the movie may be stupid, but the movie itself will make or not make its own case. Right now the whole thing's reminding me that once upon a time the big issue with Citizen Kane was supposed to be whether or not Welles had been fair to William Randolph Hearst.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • REPUBLICAN OUTREACH TO WOMEN CONTINUES.
    Good catch, Dr. Spencer : It's by Patrick Howley at The Daily Caller. Spencer believes it to be "officially the Dumbest Thing on t...
  • CONSERVATIVE MINORITY OUTREACH CONTINUES.
    Shorter Aaron Goldstein : I apologize to readers of The American Spectator -- when I celebrated Hank Aaron's baseball career, I didn...
  • EXTREMISM IN DEFENSE OF FREEBIES IS NO VICE.
    When I wrote last weekend about the Bundy Ranch situation -- in which Sagebrush Rebels threatened U.S. federal officers with violence -- I ...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about week 2 of the shutdown and the gloom gathering on the right .  Not everyone's down, though: Here's Doug Ross  with a listic...
  • SCAMDAL.
    Conservatives are all rushing forward with their dollies, showing where Big Gummint gave them bad touch. Among my favorites is Stanley Kurtz...
  • CRAZY JESUS LADY'S CRISIS OF AUTHORITY.
    Peggy Noonan has reanimated Robert Taft so that he may opine on the recent shutdown. I gotta tell you, folks, I hardly know what to do with...
  • (no title)
    NEW VOICE COLUMN UP , about the news that the U.S. birth rate is way down and how rightbloggers have reacted to it. Short version: This is...
  • NEW VILLAGE VOICE COLUMN UP...
    ...about the Crimea crisis and the rightblogger angle that a real man/President would be kicking Putin's ass right now -- you know, lik...
  • MAN OF CONSTANT SORROW.
    As I was watching the Coen Brothers 60s-folk-scene movie Inside Llewyn Davis I thought: Boy, sometimes the Coens just dump shit on a guy. ...
  • NOTHING MEANS NOTHING ANYMORE.
    At PJ Media, Rand Simberg headlines, We are all scientists and uses a cute, familiar routine to demonstrate this ("If you’ve ever gone...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2014 (179)
    • ►  August (2)
    • ►  July (28)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (25)
    • ►  March (24)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (28)
  • ►  2013 (286)
    • ►  December (23)
    • ►  November (24)
    • ►  October (23)
    • ►  September (22)
    • ►  August (20)
    • ►  July (24)
    • ►  June (24)
    • ►  May (24)
    • ►  April (28)
    • ►  March (23)
    • ►  February (23)
    • ►  January (28)
  • ▼  2012 (35)
    • ▼  December (25)
      • MORE ANNALS OF THE CULTURE WARS.
      • JON SWIFT ROUNDUP'S POSTED.
      • IF AT FIRST YOU DON'T SUCCEED, CRY, CRY AGAIN.
      • GALT 2.0.
      • GOD AND SINNERS RECONCILED.
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP
      • YOUR GUESS IS AS GOOD AS MINE.
      • ANNALS OF THE CULTURE WARS. Culture warriors are h...
      • FIGHTING WORDS. Before approving the protest of Er...
      • FROM THEIR WARM, STICKY HANDS. I trawl other blogs...
      • NEW ON THE BLOGROLL. My old friend Joe Mackin had ...
      • GO AHEAD, TRY IT THAT WAY. I'm always eager to lea...
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP, about the brethren's reaction...
      • CULTURE COPS, OUTREACH DIVISION. Ole Perfesser Gle...
      • WELL, YOU TRIED, PART II. Ace of Spades, whom we d...
      • WELL, YOU TRIED. Hey guess what -- Ace of Spades i...
      • MISTER, I MET A MAN ONCE. At National Review, Davi...
      • THUMBS DOWN. I hate to get on Glenn Greenwald's ba...
      • CLOSET CASE. Ace of Spades:Conservatives who live ...
      • THE TRUTH REVEALED! You heard that Obama has to ta...
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP, about the GOP's new attitudes...
      • A LITTLE GOOD NEWS. At Zero Hedge we hear from Bra...
      • STILL ON MOOCHER PATROL. Remember when Virginia wa...
      • GOIN' UP THE COUNTRY. I am indebted to Travis Gett...
      • NEW VOICE COLUMN UP, about the news that the U.S. ...
    • ►  November (10)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

dimple
View my complete profile